The short answer: use penny sleeves for anything you store, toploader or ship, and standard-size deck sleeves for cards you play. Pokemon cards are standard size, so any sleeve labelled standard fits; Japanese-size sleeves do not. Perfect fit inner sleeves only matter if you double sleeve a deck.
The three kinds of sleeve
| Sleeve | Use it for | Wrong for |
|---|---|---|
| Penny sleeve (soft, clear, thin) | Storage, toploaders, one-touches, shipping | Shuffling; long-term handling |
| Perfect fit (tight inner sleeve) | The inner layer when double sleeving | Going into a toploader on its own (no real benefit) |
| Deck sleeve (thicker, colored back) | Decks you shuffle and play | Toploaders and binders (too snug) |
Penny sleeves: the default
Across thousands of orders, every card I shipped went out in a penny sleeve, and it is the first layer under every holder in the protection guide. They cost about a cent each in packs of 100 or more, so buy them in bulk. Slide the card in top first and hold it by the edges, so the sleeve opening never drags across the surface.
Deck sleeves: for cards you play
Deck sleeves are thicker, have an opaque colored back, and shuffle without sticking. A 60-card deck needs a pack of at least 60. Matte backs shuffle more easily than gloss. Keep them for decks; a binder pocket or toploader built for a bare card fits a deck-sleeved card too tightly.
Perfect fits and double sleeving
A perfect fit hugs the card. Put the card in it, then slide it into a deck sleeve from the opposite end, so dust and drinks have no straight path in. It matters for a tournament deck you carry around. For a collection sitting in a box, a single penny sleeve does the same job for less.
What to buy
Code THELAB takes 10% off at BCW- Penny sleeves: the everyday sleeve for storage and toploadersBCW −10%
- Deck sleeves: standard size, for cards you shuffleBCW −10%
- Sleeve + toploader combo (100 ct): penny sleeves with toploaders to matchBCW −10%
Disclosure: these are affiliate links. Using them (or code THELAB at BCW) supports The Lab at no cost to you. How the code works
